quiz 既mc題 =[

小霞的fans

1. BALLS A AND B ARE THROWN VERTICALLY UPWARDS AND DOWNWARDS RESPECTIVELY

if their initial speeds are the same,which of the following statements is/are correct when they meet ?

1) their displacement should be the same
2)their speeds should be the same
3)their accelerations should be the same

a.1 only
b.3 only
c.1 and 2 only
d.1 and 3 only

ms 我已經錯...唉 .. phy 又可能唔合格啦

abc666

對不起...不知為什麼看錯問題,竟然看多了「same initial postion」...

鴨

原帖由 小霞的fans 於 12/12/2008 06:19 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

咁我如果take downward direction of ballA 係positive
咁佢既a 就-10^-2 因為佢向上升
咁我take downward direction of ball B 係 positive
咁佢既a咪係10^2 囉 ..因為佢向下跌

咁2個既acceleration咪唔 ...

不...
它們兩個的a也是向著地面10ms-1
就算define了不同方向是正...
所得出的結果也同樣是向著地面的方向10ms-1...
所有的東西關注的是方向而不是單純的正負...

sapphire

原帖由 小霞的fans 於 12/12/2008 06:19 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

咁我如果take downward direction of ballA 係positive
咁佢既a 就-10^-2 因為佢向上升
咁我take downward direction of ball B 係 positive
咁佢既a咪係10^2 囉 ..因為佢向下跌

咁2個既acceleration咪唔 ...

Direction is defined when you start to do a question, NOT for each object = =|||
I have said before, NO MATTER the object is moving up or moving down, its acceleration due to gravity is ALWAYS towards the ground.
NOT related to "佢向上升" or "佢向下跌"

[ 本帖最後由 sapphire 於 12/12/2008 06:32 PM 編輯 ]

小霞的fans

原帖由 sapphire 於 11/12/2008 10:01 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

For calculation, direction can be defined as you like.
If you define upward as positive, then its acceleration is -10ms^(-2)
If you define downward as positive, then its acceleration is 10ms^(-2)

咁我如果take downward direction of ballA 係positive
咁佢既a 就-10^-2 因為佢向上升
咁我take downward direction of ball B 係 positive
咁佢既a咪係10^2 囉 ..因為佢向下跌

咁2個既acceleration咪唔同lor ..咁點解3)會岩 ..
呢個係我一直想問既問題

sapphire

原帖由 小霞的fans 於 12/12/2008 05:36 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

咁TAKE XXX DIRECTION AS POSITIVE 有咩用..
點都係正 =_= "" 我太笨 ..

For calculation, direction can be defined as you like.
If you define upward as positive, then its acceleration is -10ms^(-2)
If you define downward as positive, then its acceleration is 10ms^(-2)

小霞的fans

原帖由 sapphire 於 11/12/2008 09:18 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

Remember that a negative acceleration means that the objects is accelerating in the opposite direction.

Same as your case, consider downward as positive.
Consider the motion of the object which  ...

咁TAKE XXX DIRECTION AS POSITIVE 有咩用..
點都係正 =_= "" 我太笨 ..

sapphire

原帖由 小霞的fans 於 12/12/2008 04:41 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

唔係向下果個正10 .. 向上果個-10咩 ? 佢反地心吸力- ,-

Remember that a negative acceleration means that the objects is accelerating in the opposite direction.

Same as your case, consider downward as positive.
Consider the motion of the object which is moving upward, its speed towards upward is in fact decreasing. That means the object is upward decelerating (accelerating downward).
So, if you consider the object moving upward has a negative acceleration. It means that this object is upward accelerating. Clearly it is impossible unless there is a great force provided to the object against the gravity. (Try to think if you throw a ball to the sky and it never falls down again......)
The object is actually accelerating downward. Its acceleration is also positive.

For any object in the air, its acceleration is always toward the ground if there is no other force.

[ 本帖最後由 sapphire 於 12/12/2008 05:24 PM 編輯 ]

小霞的fans

原帖由 sapphire 於 11/12/2008 08:26 PM 發表

                               
登錄/註冊後可看大圖

1) their displacement should be the same
This is true if and only if the starting point of two objects are the same

2)their speeds should be the same
This is true if and only if their meeting poi ...

唔係向下果個正10 .. 向上果個-10咩 ? 佢反地心吸力- ,-

sapphire

1) their displacement should be the same
This is true if and only if the starting point of two objects are the same

2)their speeds should be the same
This is true if and only if their meeting point is at the ground, i.e. both of the speed of the objects = 0 ms^(-2)

3)their accelerations should be the same
Acceleration due to gravity at the same place for any objects should be the same. Its direction is always towards the ground, no matter the object is moving up or moving down.

So 3 is always true.

[ 本帖最後由 sapphire 於 12/12/2008 05:25 PM 編輯 ]