[debate]你認為病毒係咪生物？

dolphin_ice

你認為病毒係咪生物？

請表明立場、以科學角度支持自己論點。

dolphin_ice

係呀﹐不過目前醫學上唔當病毒係生物。

1. 病毒0係生物學冇分界(Kingdom)
2. 病毒並冇學名(Latin name), 只有病毒號碼。(eg: H5N1, H5N2, O157)

鬼鬼

呢一個問題生理學界爭論得最勁的問題之一 ~.~|||

dolphin_ice

可以叫 bios, 不過係希臘文。

病毒...有D人會叫佢做單細胞生物ge...

不過does not eat, does not grow就...

雖然可以duplicate, 但係DNA都得。DNA唔係生物la明顯。

JOHNLAM17

Originally posted by eeEric at 2005-4-11 12:11 AM:
Virus......
It isnt with cell,
but 生物(How to call it in English?) with cell

If you believe with god, I think you must think virus is a kind of 生物 cause of god......(god made anything)

生物 refer living things

I think

orb

Virus......
It isnt with cell,
but 生物(How to call it in English?) with cell

If you believe with god, I think you must think virus is a kind of 生物 cause of god......(god made anything)

dolphin_ice

Originally posted by hinchun34 at 2005-4-2 02:24 PM:
i think 病毒in some way is 生物, and in some way isn't 生物.
because 病毒 is to attack us,for example, computer virus is a virus which make our computer to hanage,but it is made by people(離題中). ...

病毒does NOT eat!!!! :em16:

hinchun34

i think 病毒in some way is 生物, and in some way isn't 生物.
because 病毒 is to attack us,for example, computer virus is a virus which make our computer to hanage,but it is made by people(離題中). in here, 病毒 is 徵生物, this is to入侵our body to have some病,for example,愛滋病 makes our免疫能力下降, if they can make us, so they can move or eat, so they are 病毒.

secret

Originally posted by jbano2 at 2005-4-2 12:36 AM:


本身萬物同出一徹,
都是由原子(如果再細D就夸克了=.=)組成,
滅亡後又帶來誔生,誔生後又再滅亡.
形成生命的循環.
而星體甚至生物還不是照着這循環存在着,
直到宇宙消失.這正是「 ...

是的...難道我是說星體的"生命"嗎?我說的是生物的生命!不是
所謂星體的"生命"!如果是這樣的話,那麼電池也可以算是有生命的了,
因為電池也有"壽命"!

jbano2

Originally posted by secret at 2005-4-1 10:01 PM:
我覺得是...雖然它們不符合七大特徵,但它們也是有生命的

本身萬物同出一徹,
都是由原子(如果再細D就夸克了=.=)組成,
滅亡後又帶來誔生,誔生後又再滅亡.
形成生命的循環.
而星體甚至生物還不是照着這循環存在着,
直到宇宙消失.這正是「宇宙生命」的奧義!

所以只要有誔生和滅亡的,都可叫「生命」!!
所以請你說請楚,是要說生物的生命嗎?